| Year | All-MCC | MCC Honorable Mention | MCC Player of the Week |
| 2011 | McKenzie Thompson | Kendra King | McKenzie Thompson (10/10) |
| Liz Gbur | Melissa Backes (10/10) | ||
| Kendra King (11/7) | |||
| Liz Gbur (10/10, 10/31, 11/7) | |||
| 2010 | Kelsay McCausland | Hanna Bruns | Tara Van Zuiden (9/6) |
| Yawen Xiao | Liz Gbur (9/6) | ||
| 2009 | Kelsay McCausland | Allison Uceda (9/28) | |
| Allison Uceda | Kelsay McCausland (9/28, 11/9) | ||
| Tara Van Zuiden (9/28) | |||
| 2008 | Jenny Buelow | Kelsay McCausland | |
| Aubree Rhoades | |||
| 2007 | Jenny Buelow | Kristin Orozco | |
| Aubree Rhoades | Kelsay McCausland | ||
| 2006 | Jenny Buelow | Kristin Orozco | |
| Aubree Rhoades | |||
| 2005 | Jenny Buelow | Amanda Deters | |
| Stacy Cook | Jessie Kearns | ||
| Kristin Orozco | |||
| 2004 | Kelli Guth | ||
| Sarah Deters | |||
| Erin Johnson | |||
| Jessie Kearns | |||
| 2003 | Kelli Guth | ||
| Kimberly Richard | |||
| Elizabeth Way | |||
| 2002 | Allison Jones (2nd Team) | Jenny Knutsen | |
| Kim Richard | |||
| Elizabeth Way | |||
| 2001 | Allison Jones | Sarah Behl | |
| Jenny Knutsen | |||
| 2000 | Sarah Behl (2nd Team) | ||
| 1999 | Kristy Gertson | Bridget Luby | |
| Carrie Honeywell (2nd Team) | Carrie Pepper | ||
| 1998 | Jessica Geronzin | Carrie Honeywell | |
| Kristy Gertson (2nd Team) | Bridget Luby | ||
| 1997 | Janet Flood (2nd Team) | Cheri Keske | |
| Jessica Geronzin (2nd Team) | Bridget Luby | ||
| 1996 | Jessica Geronzin (2nd Team) | Sheila Barsema | |
| Carey Willis | |||
| 1995 | Stacey Powers | ||
| Heather Hilgendorf | |||
| Shelly Mohr | |||
| Steph Wheeler | |||
| 1994 | Jennifer Miles | ||
| 1993 | Theresa Thiessen | ||
| 1989 | Michelle Clouse | ||
| Deb Turner |
| Year | |||
| 2010 | Kelsay McCausland | Tara Van Zuiden | Hanna Bruns |
| 2009 | Kelsay McCausland | Tara Van Zuiden | Lisa LaMasse |
| Breelyn McMahon | Rachel Caulkins | ||
| 2008 | Breelyn McMahon | Alisha Parker | Aubree Rhoades |
| 2007 | Aubree Rhoades | ||
| 2005 | Stacy Cook | ||
| 2004 | Shayla Franzen | Kelli Guth | |
| 2003 | Shayla Franzen | Kelli Guth | Elizabeth Way |
| 2002 | Jennifer Knutsen | Elizabeth Way | |
| 2001 | Amanda Machael |
| Year | ||||
| 2011 | Melissa Backes | Katelyn Hasken | Mackenzie McCutcheon | Danielle Tombolato |
| Micah Wedemeier | ||||
| 2010 | Hanna Bruns | Liz Gbur | Kelsay McCausland | Samantha Moller |
| Jessie Tompkins | Tara Van Zuiden | Yawen Xiao | ||
| 2009 | Hanna Bruns | Rachel Caulkins | Kelsay McCausland | Heather McCue |
| Breelyn McMahon | Samantha Moller | Tara Van Zuiden | Beth Wenzel | |
| 2008 | Abigail Adams | Rachel Caulkins | Piper Coakley | Kayla Fussner |
| Lisa LaMasse | Kelsay McCausland | Breelyn McMahon | Samantha Moller | |
| Kristin Orozco | Alisha Parker | Aubree Rhoades | Rebecca Soesbe | |
| Tara Van Zuiden | Beth Wenzel | |||
| 2007 | Aubree Rhoades | Melissa Daniels | Michelle Kramer | Breelyn McMahon |
| Kristin Orozco | Alisha Parker | |||
| 2005 | Valerie Boles | Stacy Cook | Sara Deters | Stacy Lawrence |
| 2004 | Kelli Guth | Erin Daniels | Shayla Franzen | Stacy Lawrence |
| Lindsey Reid | Kimberly Richard | Erin Johnson | Sara Deters | |
| 2003 | Ashley Adams | Valerie Boles | Erin Daniels | Shayla Franzen |
| Kelli Guth | Lindsey Reid | Kimberly Richard | Jenny Schulte | |
| Elizabeth Way | ||||
| 2002 | Jennifer Knutsen | Elizabeth Way | ||
| 2001 | Amanda Machael | Allison Jones | Jenny Knutsen | Jennifer Schulte |
| Elizabeth Way | ||||
| 2000 | Cindy Burdette | Amanda Machael | ||
| 1999 | Cindy Burdette | Kristy Gertson | Carrie Honeywell | Bridget Luby |
| Amanda Norman | Carrie Pepper | |||
| 1997 | Andrea Engelkens | Carrie Honeywell | Elizabeth Jansen | Bridget Luby |
| Amanda Norman | Carrie Pepper | Carrie Taylor | Kelly Venema | |
| Michelle Wise | ||||
| 1996 | Dawn Alms | Andrea Engelkens | Heather Hilgendorf | Hiedi Hill |
| Jennifer Houzenga | Elizabeth Jansen | Michelle Wise | ||
| 1995 | Heather Hilgendorf | Stacy Mohr | Stacey Powers | |
| 1994 | Michelle Scott | Shelly Mohr | Carey Willis | |
| 1992 | Michelle Clouse | Teresa Thiessen | Deborah Huizenga | Nicole Crider |
| Jennifer Drey | Sybil Blount |
2008 NAIA Scholar-Team Award
2010 AVCA All-Midwest Region Team - Yawen Xiao
2009 AVCA Honorable Mention All-Midwest Region Team - Kelsay McCausland
2008 AVCA-NAIA Third Team All-American - Jenny Buelow
2008 NAIA Honorable Mention All-American - Jenny Buelow
2008 NAIA First Team All-Midwest Region - Jenny Buelow
2007 NAIA All-Region VII Second Team - Jenny Buelow
2006 NAIA All-Region VII Second Team - Jenny Buelow
2005 NAIA All-Region VII First Team - Jenny Buelow
2005 NAIA All-Region VII Second Team - Stacy Cook


