Baseball Honors
Conference Awards
| Year | All-MCC | MCC Honorable Mention | MCC Gold Glove | MCC Athlete of the Week |
| 2012 | Gary Mayberry | Gary Mayberry | Pat Macaione (2/27) | |
| R.J. Roberts | Zach Smerz (3/12) | |||
| Pat Macaione | Damil Reyes (2/20, 2/27 & 4/16) | |||
| Damil Reyes | Ian Hamilton (4/16) | |||
| 2011 | Jordan Nuss | Nathan Grier | Jordan Nuss | Billy Becker (3/28) |
| Billy Becker | Mike Ray | Billy Becker | ||
| 2010 | Austin Poindexter | J.D. Fabian (4/6) | ||
| Mike Ray | Billy Becker (3/22) | |||
| 2009 | Brian Cummings | Jake Steve | Brian Cummings | |
| 2008 | Tyler Sukut | Adam Wojciechowski | ||
| 2003 | Ryan Miller | |||
| 2002 | John Zeller | |||
| 1999 | Jason Kapaun |
NAIA Scholar-Athlete Awards
| Year | ||||
| 2012 | Tim Elias | Rafael Ordaz | Michael Bruns | Joseph Dashek |
| 2011 | Tim Elias | |||
| 2009 | Brian Cummings | |||
| 2006 | John Cummings |
MCC All-Academic Awards
| Year | ||||
| 2012 | Michael Bruns | Ryan Bumphrey | Tomas Chardon | Joe Dashek |
| Tim Elias | Ryan Fraley | Brandon Haines | Ian Hamilton | |
| Mitch Jankowski | Kyler Kopach | Pat Macaione | Tanner McLaughlin | |
| Rafael Ordaz | Damil Reyes | R.J. Roberts | Zach Smerz | |
| Matt Wohrley | ||||
| 2011 | Marc Arsenault | James Bench | Michael Bruns | Jeran Courtney |
| Joe Dashek | Tim Elias | Jason Fletcher | Nathan Grier | |
| Brandon Haines | Jeremy Jayaweera | Jared Jones | Anthony Misitano | |
| Rafael Ordaz | Chris Thompson | Matt Wohrley | Adam Wojciechowski | |
| 2010 | Hunter Allspaugh | Nick Davis | Tim Elias | Jason Fletcher |
| Mitch Jankowski | Nolan McNeill | Jordan Wakeley | Adam Wojciechowski | |
| 2009 | Hunter Allspaugh | Brian Cummings | Scott Schmitt | Jake Steve |
| Adam Wojciechowski | ||||
| 2008 | Jake Steve | Brian Cummings | ||
| 2005 | John Cummings | Chris Gosnell | Matt Naftzger | |
| 2004 | John Cummings | Chris Gosnell | Honorio Lozano | Aaron Marshall |
| Ryan Miller | Adam West | Gary Wolke | ||
| 2003 | David Gerth | Jason Harynuk | Honorio Lozano | Ryan Miller |
| Chris Souders | ||||
| 2002 | David Gerth | Honorio Lozano | Andrew Steines | |
| 2001 | Kyle Lentz | Lee Maunu | Chad Siebel | Cameron Smith |
| Andrew Steines | ||||
| 2000 | Daniel Clarke | Paul Daniels | Jason Kapaun | Lee Maunu |
| Joseph May | ||||
| 1999 | Chad Jilek | Jason Kapaun | ||
| 1998 | Joseph Roberts | |||
| 1997 | Scott Horst | Mitch Musial | ||
| 1995 | Jerry Christansen |
Individual Awards
2012 Capital One CoSIDA All-Academic First Team All-Region Five - Ryan Fraley
Team Awards
2011 NAIA Scholar-Team Award
